People With Bad Constitutional Foundations End Up with Bad Constitutional Opinions

July 30, 2018  By   Mike Maharrey   

Tenth Amendment Center

A lot of people seem to believe Pres. Donald Trump is some kind of limited government constitutionalist. He’s not.

The other day, I got an email from a guy who embraces this idea. He claimed Trump “unwittingly embraces the fundamental ideals of the founders: ie. a smaller unobtrusive laissez-faire government, with emphasis on individual liberty via merit.”

People who have a poor constitutional foundation end up with really convoluted constitutional opinions – like this guy. Whether you like Trump or not, you simply can’t believe he “embraces the fundamental ideals of the founders” if you understand what those ideals actually were.

For instance, Trump has continued the federal surveillance state unabated. But general warrants that authorized British agents to enter and search homes and businesses without any probable cause was one of the first flashpoints between colonists and the British government more than a decade before the colonists declared independence. These warrants never expired and didn’t specify what was to be searched for. Writs of assistance were completely open-ended. The Fourth Amendment was proposed and ratified as a direct result of this struggle. A president who embraced the fundamental ideals of the founders would have shut down the NSA’s warrantless surveillance program on day one. Trump didn’t. In fact, he extended it and nominated a Supreme Court justice who helped write the Patriot Act.

Or how about war? The U.S. dropped 44,000 bombs in 2017 without a constitutionally required declaration of war. The framers of the Constitution deliberately withheld the power to make war from the president. As James Madison asserted in a letter to Thomas Jefferson:

The constitution supposes, what the History of all Governments demonstrates, that the Executive is the branch of power most interested in war, & most prone to it. It has accordingly with studied care, vested the question of war in the Legislature.

Trump’s bombing campaigns do not reflect the “fundamental ideals of the founders.”

Of course, the right to keep and bear arms was certainly a fundamental ideal held by the founding generation. The people of the states insisted on ratifying an amendment that prohibits the federal government from enforcing any law that infringes on that right. Yet the Trump administration has ramped up enforcement of unconstitutional federal gun laws. During the first year of the Trump administration, the ATF investigated 3,349 more firearms cases than it did during the last year of the Obama presidency.

And most recently, Trump proposed a $12 billion bailout for farmers. The administration claims the the Commodity Credit Corporation Charter Act, a Depression-era funding program that doesn’t require approval from Congress, authorizes the handout. Of course, it doesn’t. The Constitution delegates no such power to the federal government.

I could go on. The Trump administration has continued the unconstitutional drug war, ramped up asset forfeiture and added billions of dollars to the federal budget.

None of this reflects the “fundamental ideals of the founders.” None of it is unobtrusive. And you can’t define any of it as remotely laissez-faire. Only somebody with a really shoddy constitutional foundation could make such an obviously absurd statement. Read more at Tenth Amendment Center

Views: 87

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I'm starting to see a trend.. with 10th amendment center. It looks a little like trying to divide Trump's base. In both this article and Judge Nap's 10th amendment center article 'The Rule of Law Doesn't Exist in DC' there is an overlying tone of 'the president is all-powerful' even when the within the article it points out that the president doesn't make law and is not above law. I find the topics of interest they are using important like them, like NSA shouldn't be spying on us all, but due to the luvly PATRIOT ACT it's law that it does. Should Trump rise above the law and shut it down by executive order?? 

I'm completely uninformed about the farmers' tariff bailout, and it does sound like something he would probably encourage congress to do to smooth over his shift in foreign policy. But did he make it happen with a waive of his all-powerful hand or did congress have to write something to finance the farmers' tariff bail-out?? 

I'm seeing a trend of 10th amendment center speaking with forked tongue on such matters, oddly looking like it's maybe trying to divide Trump's base for the never-Trumpers. Wonder how much of their financing comes from the Koch brothers....


 Please donate to TCC.  Your Contribution is greatly appreciated. Donate safely and securely through PayPal

Latest Activity

Larry Puckette replied to Suzie Nielsen's discussion The Goal-Muslim America-the Plan Education
"'since 1989'... yep, a couple other things that were rarely publicized about what islam…"
8 hours ago
LANYON posted discussions
8 hours ago
Patricia Gillenwater replied to Patricia Gillenwater's discussion Think About It Using Common Sense
"Yes Suzie you are one busy lady. Suspect that is in you DNA. One of the thoughts I had was a good…"
Patricia Gillenwater replied to Patricia Gillenwater's discussion Think About It Using Common Sense
"Yes Suzi a momentous task before us. Yet we will try. Become a PC and Will too I cannot think of…"
Patricia Gillenwater replied to LANYON's discussion How Fake News Could Be A Backdoor to Tyranny
"Obviously it is. I will always come down on the side of liberty, freedom of speech. I can not…"
luis✩USA replied to Larry Puckette's discussion My random topics thread ...
"POOR, POOR CNN Despite 2 yrs of outright lies about Trump 24/7, a CNN poll shows that the…"
Patricia Gillenwater posted a discussion

Think About It Using Common Sense

WARNING: This is not an easy nor pleasant read. Even if what I offer as opinion does not happen it…See More
Larry Puckette replied to Suzie Nielsen's discussion Liars! Cheats! And Thief's!
"Liars, cheats and thieves -- 1st thing that came to my mind was 'politicians'.. in…"

Volcano's and Earthquakes

Your Contribution is Greatly Appreciated

Donate safely and securely through PayPal

© 2019   Created by Suzie Nielsen.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service